Chapter 9
Everything But The Truth
I was elbow-deep in Sylvie's tea shelves, trying to work out why half her labeling system made sense only to her, when my phone buzzed with one word from Finneas. Pie. From him, lately, that meant come to The Tidal Spoon now, and don't ask why over text.
I flipped the shop's sign to Closed and walked to the diner, past window boxes that hadn't gotten the memo that it's now October, and on past the huge oak in the center of town.
He was already seated at our usual table when I got there, notebook open to a fresh page, a slice of berry pie à la mode in front of him that he clearly had no plans to eat.

“My guy at the paper called back,” he said, before I'd even slid into the booth.
“Good morning to you too.”
“You know what else he discovered about Aldous Creed? Apparently, the good reverend's son leads this enormous televangelist church in Portsmouth.” He turned the notebook so I could see a few lines of his shorthand. “There was a settlement a few months back…" he smirked. "To a former staff member, in an undisclosed amount, that was scrubbed off the local news before it ever even ran. My guy only found it because he still has a source at the paper that leaked the story.”
“Soo…the story is about his son. Not Creed?”
“Well, kind of.” He sounded skeptical. “Creed frequently drives down to Portsmouth. Seems he's more than a proud father visiting his successful son's church. In my guy's words — people in the religious community have noticed.”
“So what?” I shrugged.
“It's not exactly evidence of anything," he hedged. "But it's something I can't stop thinking about.”
I didn't have a response to that, so I let it sit between us.
“On another front, there's Carol,” he said, flipping to a new page. “From the hardware store.”
“You've had a busy morning.”
“Yeah. Anyhow, Carol flagged me down on the street before I'd even gotten my coffee.” He tapped the page. “She heard I was investigating Granny Orin's disappearance, and wanted to tell me that she saw Dale Pruett's truck at the curb outside Granny's gate two nights before you found the cottage door open. Around eleven pm. Engine running, lights off.”
“That's oddly specific for a passing glance.”
“It wasn't passing. She noticed because that end of the green doesn't get vehicle traffic after nine o'clock — it's the flagstone path, with foot access only. There's no legitimate place to park a truck along that stretch. And because half this town knows Pruett and Orinthia hadn't exchanged a civil word in more than two years.” He shrugged. “She just thought that a Pruett truck sitting outside her gate was…unusual.”
I sat. “Well, it's interesting. That's for sure.”
“There's more.” He flipped to another page. “That zoning file Elias pulled for us? Well, buried in the final pages, I found a financial disclosure. Curiously, Dale Pruett stands to make some real money if that parcel goes to a developer instead of staying in Granny's control. Six figures. Not some vague future benefit.”
“So, you're saying he had motive to want her gone? And his truck just happened to be seen outside her gate the night she vanished?” I picked up my fork but didn't use it. “Finneas, that's — ”
“I know what it looks like.”
I turned the notebook back around and read Carol's account twice. People telling you what they saw fall into two piles — the ones certain because they actually saw it, and the ones certain because certainty feels better than not knowing. Carol's account read like the first kind. A specific time, and specific details about the engine and the lights. This didn't sound like embellishment.
“You believe her,” Finneas said, watching my face.
“I believe she saw what she says she saw.” I slid the notebook back. “Whether that means what it looks like it means is a different question.”
“And the disclosure?”
“It's technically a matter of public record. Buried is the operative word — it's an addendum filed separately from the main zoning packet, three pages of numbers nobody reads unless they're already looking for a reason to.” He tapped the relevant line. “Elias didn't flag it. I don't think he'd read that far in.”
Dottie arrived with the coffee pot, topping off both our cups without request.
“You two investigating that zoning mess?” she asked. “Because I'll tell you what, Dale Pruett stood up at the last town meeting and said something about how certain people who think they can see the future ought to mind their own business instead.” She set the pot down with a decisive clink. “Everybody in that room knew exactly who he meant.”
“Did he say Granny Orin's name, specifically?” Finneas asked.
“He didn't have to.” Dottie wiped a spot on the table that didn't need wiping, clearly angling for a reason to stay in the conversation a bit longer than she should. Then she straightened and was already moving toward the register, refilling someone else's cup along the way, like she'd delivered exactly as much information as she'd intended to and not one word more.
Finneas wrote something down and underlined it twice.
“It fits,” I said, staring at the pie I wasn't really eating.
“A little too well.” He hadn't written anything about Pruett in several minutes. “I've met Dale Pruett twice now. Both times he reminded me of someone who's spent his whole career being underestimated and decided to make everyone pay for it. That's not evidence. That's just a bad feeling I can't back up.”
“Sometimes a bad feeling is the only thing you have until the evidence catches up.”
“Sure.” He didn't sound convinced.
“And Creed just gets a settlement nobody explained and a gut feeling?”
“For now.” He closed the notebook halfway. “I want to sit in on Sunday's sermon before I do anything else with him. See how he runs a room when he thinks nobody's paying attention.”
“I want to go with you.”
He looked up. “It's church, Briar. Not a stakeout.”
“I've been in this town three weeks, and I still haven't set foot in a church. Seems like an oversight I should correct.” I said it lightly, but some part of me had already decided, and it wasn't lost on Finneas.
He studied me for a second longer than the excuse required. “Okay,” he said. “Sunday, it is. Both of us.”
“You think a sermon's going to tell you something a phone call won't.”
“I think how a man performs in public says more about him than any file ever will.” He shrugged, like it wasn't worth defending further. “Call it instinct.”
“Your instinct's had a pretty good week.”
“My instinct's had a confusing week,” he said.
I thought about the Three of Swords — the grief, the fear, and the other, colder thing underneath that I still hadn't figured out. Pruett was loud and financially motivated and, by every measure currently sitting on the table between us, had both means and opportunity.
But he didn't feel like grief.
He felt like money.
Whatever I'd touched on in that cold little reading room had felt like someone Granny Orin trusted completely, right up until she didn't. I could still call up the specifics if I let myself — the dark cloth on the table, the two chairs angled toward each other like they'd been arranged for a conversation, the cold that had come off the Three of Swords before I was even expecting anything. Pruett had never had that kind of relationship with her. Everyone in town agreed, even the people who were perfectly happy to think he'd done it. Dale Pruett had been her adversary in public, loudly, for two years. They fought in front of witnesses; it wasn't a betrayal. Betrayal needed closeness first, and Pruett had never been close.
I didn't say any of this out loud. I wasn't sure yet how to say it without sounding like I was arguing against the very evidence Finneas had just handed himself, page by page, over pie he still hadn't touched. So I waited. I knew how to do that — I'd done it enough times, watching a chart come back with a number that wouldn't mean what the family in the waiting room was hoping for, to know there was no rushing the moment before you said it out loud.
“We should talk to him,” I said instead.
“Pruett? I'm meeting with him tomorrow morning, before he's had coffee and his guard's still up.” Finneas closed the notebook the rest of the way. “And I'll keep investigating Creed in the meantime.”
“Do it quietly.”
“I will.”
I looked out the window at the green, at the oak losing the last of its leaves in slow, deliberate spirals, and past it, over the rooftops, the church spire Finneas kept not-quite-looking at every time we walked this stretch of Main Street.
Everything currently pointing at Dale Pruett was on point.
None of it, however, felt like the truth.
Finneas walked me back as far as the corner where our paths split, his notebook tucked under one arm like something that might get away from him if he wasn't careful. He didn't say anything else about Creed. I didn't ask him to. Whatever he'd started pulling on, he was going to keep pulling on it alone for now, and some part of me understood that better than I wanted to — the instinct to run down a thread quietly before handing anyone else a reason to doubt it.
“Tomorrow,” he said, at the corner. “Pruett first. Then Sunday, and whatever a sermon looks like when you're observing for very different reasons.”
“Let's try not to get thrown out.” I laughed.
“I'm very good at looking like I belong places.” He said it without a trace of a smile, and I knew he meant it as a joke. “It's a professional skill.”
He turned toward the Inn, and I watched him go for a minute longer than necessary, then I told myself it was because I was tired, and headed for the shop.
Back at the shop, the brooch was sitting on the counter where I'd left it that morning, catching the last of the streetlight through the front window. I didn't pick it up. I stood there for a moment anyway, one hand flat on the counter beside it, thinking about a red circle pressed hard enough into paper to nearly tear it, and a man standing up at a town meeting to say something ugly about a woman who could apparently see things he didn't want seen.
It fit Pruett. It fit him so well I could have closed the case myself, right there, standing in an empty shop with cold coffee in my system and a raven somewhere out on the green.
The obvious answer is frequently the right one. But sometimes everything on paper lines up and something underneath it still feels wrong, and there's nothing to do but sit with that until you can figure it out.
I locked the door and went to bed already rehearsing what I'd say to a man I'd never met, tomorrow morning, before his coffee kicked in and his guard came up.